sajm





PDF Print E-mail
Written by Administrator   

Breaking the Deadlocks of Trial Court Management in West Bengal: A Heuristic Approach

Pradip Banerjee* and Pritam Banerjee**

DOI: https://doi.org/10.62206/sajm.31.1.2024.168-184

PUBLISHED : 25 JUNE 2024

Abstract

It is undeniable that most of the judges in India are overburdened with extensive jurisdiction over both judicial as well as administrative functions of the court, and in effect the Judiciary, the guardian of the Indian Constitution, is suffering from a managerial crisis. The emerging concept of court management is not similar to administration of justice and even quite different from case-management. This study is about the concept of court management; identifies six grey managerial areas along with twelve tentative reformative measures for trial courts’ management. The identified reformative measures then have been empirically verified and arranged in a sequential order as per the response of different frontline stakeholders (Judges, Lawyers, Academicians, and Administrators) of the justice delivery system. While analyzing those data as collected from the field study, this research heuristically found that any reform (like increasing the working time of judges), which may appear to be the most appropriate action, may not be comprehensive from the perception of every stakeholder. The findings of this paper suggests that the court-management is not a matter of grundnorm, rather it needs to be implemented through proper consultation with principal judges of every district or subordinate courts, respective Bar associations, associations of court employees and other primary stakeholders.

Key Words

Administration of justice, Case management, Court management, Judicial administration, Managerial reforms in judiciary, National Court Management System (NCMS), Roadmap for district and subdivision courts

Author Biography

Pradip Banerjee
Judicial Officer, LL.B., LL.M., MBA (HR), Ph.D. (Law), Post-Doctorate (NIT, Durgapur). E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Parul Varma
Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Law, The University of Burdwan, Golapbag Campus, Burdwan-713104; and is the corresponding author. E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

References

  1. Ambwani, Justice S. (2009). Justice aministration: ‘Case and court management’, advanced course on civil process including recent trends in judgement writing27th to 31st July, 2006, National Judicial Academy, Bhopal, revised and delivered at IJTR, 31st January, 2009, 1-11.
  2. Armstrong, M. (2022). India overtakes UK to become fifth biggest economy Statista. https://www.statista.com/chart/28258/gdp-of-india-and-united-kingdom/.
  3. Balakrishnan., Justice K.G. (2008). Judicial Reforms in India, Indo-EU Business Forum, London.
  4. Banerjee, P. (2021). Inducing Competitive Advantage in Judiciary at District Level, Upholding Justice, 1st Edition, 219, Routledge India.
  5. Daksh (2017). Case Flow Management Rules in India, Daksh India, 1-8.
  6. Dhavan, Justice S.S. (1966). The Indian Judicial System: A Historical Survey, Centenary High Court of Judicature at Allahabad 1866-1966, 1, 53-95.
  7. Gupta, K. K. L. (2013). Induction of National Court Management Authority in Indian Judicial System: Need of the Hour, Live Law.
  8. Gupta, K. L., & Bhushan, T. (2022). India needs a court management authority. Economic & Political Weekly, 57(42).
  9. Hayo, B., & Voigt, S. (2013). The relevance of judicial procedure for economic growth. CESifo Economic Studies, 60(3), 490-524.
  10. Islam, K. M. B., Samarjeet, S., & Srivastav, A. K. (2017). Performance indicators for subordinate courts and suggestive policy/ procedural changes for reducing civil case pendency, Government of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, in collaboration with Indian Institute of Management, Kashipur, Uttarakhand.
  11. Jeuland, E. (2018). Towards a New Court Management? General Report, University Paris 1 Pantheon Sorbonne, hal-01680418, 4-5.
  12. Kapopoulos, P., & Rizos, A. (2021). Judicial Efficiency and Economic Growth: Evidence based on EU data. MPRA Paper 107861, University Library of Munich, Germany.
  13. Kaul, A. (2020). Role of Court Managers in Indian Judiciary. Daksh, 5.
  14. Krishnan, S.K., & Singh, M. (2011). Strategic human resource management: A three-stage process model and its influencing factors. South Asian Journal of Management, 18(1), 60
  15. Lawson, H. O., & Dennis, E. H. (1993). Development of the profession of court management: A history with commentary. Justice System Journal, 15(2), 580-604.
  16. Logasakthi, K., Prakash, M., & Singh, P. (2022). Impact of employees’ emotional intelligence on sustainable organizational development: Mediating role of organizational resilience. South Asian Journal of Management, 29(5), 28.
  17. Mahoney, Paul G. (2001). The common law and economic growth: Hayek Might Be Right. The Journal of Legal Studies, 30(2), 503-525.
  18. Malimath, Justice V. S. (2003). Committee on reforms of criminal justice system, Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, 159, 161
  19. Mehrotra, Justice R. B. (1995). Court management. Judicial Training & Research Institute Journal, U. P., 1(3).
  20. Mustafa, Prof. (Dr.) F. (2017). A study on court management techniques for improving the efficiency of subordinate courts, Government of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, in collaboration with NALSAR University of Law, 37-38.
  21. Nath, K. (2022). Around 5 crore cases are pending in courts across India, Finology [Blog post]. https://blog.finology.in/Legal-news/pending-cases-in-india
  22. Oberoi, G. (2017). The curious case of court manager in India: From its creation to its desertion. International Journal for Court Administration, 9(1).
  23. Quddhose, Justice A. (2020). Importance of Case Management and Practice Directions before Commercial Courts. Live Law.
  24. Sahoo., Justice S. K. (2018). A National Seminar on Timely Justice to the Litigants. Odisha Judicial Academy.
  25. Sahoo, N., & Khan, J. A. (2022). Improving India’s Justice Delivery System: Why Infrastructure Matters. Observer Research Foundation (ORF).
  26. Samal, A., & Chatterjee, D. (2020). Rethinking organizational change: Towards a conceptual framework. South Asian Journal of Management, 27(2), 30.
  27. Sandhya, P. R., Sharma, R.V., & Pathak, M. (2021). Draft paper on court management and case management – The past, present, and the future, Daksh Centre of Excellence for Law and Technology at IIT-Delhi (CoE).
  28. Subramanian, K. V. (2019). Ending matsyanyaya: How to ramp up capacity in the lower judiciary, economic survey 2018-19, 1, 98-114.
  29. Supreme Court of India (2018). Conference proceedings of national initiative to reduce pendency and delay in judicial system.
  30. Trewatha, R.L., & Newport, M.G. (1976). Management: Functions and Behavior, Dallas: Business Publication.
  31. Tulsyan, A. (2022). Law and Economics: The role of law and legal systems in economic development with a special emphasis on India, Manupatra.
  32. Walsh, B. (2008). Judicial productivity in India. International Journal for Court Administration, 23.
  33. Weissbrodt, D. (2009). The administration of justice and human rights. City University of Hong Kong Law Review, 1, 23.
  34. Xu, G. (2011). The role of law in economic growth: A literature review. Journal of Economic Surveys, 25(5), 833-871.